The Legacy of Maimonides: A New Worthwhile Book

The Legacy of Maimonides
Religion, Reason and Community
800th Anniversary Commemorative Collection
http://www.yasharbooks.com/Legacy.html
320 pages, $26.95 Edited by Yamin Levy and Shalom Carmy

Rabbi Moses Maimonides (1135-1204), known as Rambam, is widely known as a profound philosopher and authoritative legal scholar. However, Rambam’s contributions are not merely remnants of medieval scholarship but a vibrant legacy that gives compelling guidance in modern man’s spiritual search. In this book, leading scholars present surveys of Rambam’s thinking and his impact on Judaism, and apply Rambam’s approach to various issues of critical contemporary importance.
The opening essay in the book is by the late Professor Isadore Twersky, dean of intellectual historians working on Rambam, and himself a role model for the combination of Torah and academic scholarship. His subject is the growth of Rambam’s reputation and his impact on later Torah scholarship. Rabbi Norman Lamm, for so many years a productive scholar and leader of American Orthodoxy, discusses a question central to religious life—the love of God—drawing on Rambam’s halakhic works and the Guide. Professor Arthur Hyman, who occupies a prominent place among contemporary interpreters of Maimonides’ philosophy, surveys, with his customary concision and clarity, the broad options in the academic scholarship of the 20th century.
Contributions by Shalom Carmy and David Berger focus on critical questions regarding the ongoing implications of certain Maimonidean doctrines. Rabbi Carmy’s article offers a defense of Rambam’s robust approach to dogma. Dr. Berger explores present day utilizations of Rambam’s naturalistic teachings about the messianic age. The late educator and scholar Rabbi Norman Frimer depicts Rambam’s influence as a role model for intellectual searchers. His son, the legal scholar Dov Frimer, turns to the details of Rambam’s jurisprudence, and produces some unexpected conclusions regarding the halakhic status of non-Jews. Roslyn Weiss devotes her paper to a detailed examination of one text in the introduction to the Guide, communicating the exhilaration of such microscopic study and its more systematic pertinence.
Yamin Levy’s essay looks at the general relationship between Rambam’s championing of rational thought and the kind of community it fosters. Hayyim Angel surveys many of Rambam’s discussions pertinent to Biblical exegesis and their abiding importance for our own study of Tanakh. Elimelekh Polinsky deals with a specific area, honor and respect for parents. His essay, too, exemplifies the integrated study of Rambam’s Halakhah and his philosophy. The essays by Moshe Sokolow and Gerald Blidstein expand the scope of the book. Sokolow demonstrates the significant issues tackled by Rambam in his epistles. Blidstein, much admired for his three analytic and historical monographs on specific topics in Maimonides’ jurisprudence, discusses the idea of Oral Law in Rambam. David Shatz aptly closes the volume with an analysis of the last chapters in the Guide, casting new light on Rambam’s view of human nature, the role of the mitzvot and the goal of human existence, while demonstrating yet again the necessity of painstaking microscopic analysis of the text and its literary organization.

Contributors:
Isadore Twersky
Norman Lamm
Arthur Hyman
Shalom Carmy
David Berger
Norman Frimer
Dov Frimer
Roslyn Weiss
Yamin Levy
Hayim Angel
Elimelekh Polinsky
Moshe Sokolow
Gerald Blidstein
David Shatz